The day that happens will be the day I stop blogging. We are so successful that the main stream media, and those who oppose free speech are watching and waiting for the time to pounce. Some Catholics want to rein-in other Catholic bloggers and may appeal to various national bishops' conference for "crack-downs".
Sadly, some of the noisiest people who want blog control are neo-cons, who either do not like what the liberal Catholics are saying, or who do not like what the trad Catholics are saying.
Arrgghh.
Any type of control either from governments or bishops would be the end of freedom of speech. But too many Catholics are abusing their positions on line.
Here is a copy of a post I put on the Guild of Titus Brandsma the other day.
I repeat it here for reflection. We can be our own worst enemies.
Monday, 2 June 2014
Wise as Serpents; Guileless as Doves
We, as the blogging Catholic media, are entering into a new phase. I can see it and sense it. The main
stream media has finally realized how powerful the blogosphere is and is beginning to highlight problems,
from that point of view.
A note today in the news states that the msm is in decline because of the online media, including bloggers.
But, Catholic bloggers are now under the spotlight. We have to turn a corner. This is the "turning time."
From now on, the blogging community must be wise and prudent in the ways of the world. We not only
A note today in the news states that the msm is in decline because of the online media, including bloggers.
But, Catholic bloggers are now under the spotlight. We have to turn a corner. This is the "turning time."
From now on, the blogging community must be wise and prudent in the ways of the world. We not only
must be professional, we must argue in rational discourse and not on the level of the personal.
I taught logic and argumentation for years and have written on this blog last year on the importance of
I taught logic and argumentation for years and have written on this blog last year on the importance of
rational discourse.
Two rules: stay with the objective facts and never use personal names or get involved in personal arguments.
Debate is absolutely necessary. Apologetics in the Catholic Church demands an objectivity and the
Two rules: stay with the objective facts and never use personal names or get involved in personal arguments.
Debate is absolutely necessary. Apologetics in the Catholic Church demands an objectivity and the
virtues of prudence, temperance, justice, as well as courage.
If we are to be taken seriously, we must be serious in our approach.
Here is a review of rules for rational discourse in the form of questions:
1) Is the argument coherent, clear, based on facts?
2) Is the diction used objective?
3) Is there a clear common basis for discussion?
4) Are the arguments concise and open to modification if necessary for coherence? This does not mean
If we are to be taken seriously, we must be serious in our approach.
Here is a review of rules for rational discourse in the form of questions:
1) Is the argument coherent, clear, based on facts?
2) Is the diction used objective?
3) Is there a clear common basis for discussion?
4) Are the arguments concise and open to modification if necessary for coherence? This does not mean
changing the inherent truth of the argument, but modifying approaches.
5) Are all, and I repeat, all emotional arguments and feelings set aside?
6) Are subjective arguments rightly seen as irrelevant?
7) Are those involved courteous and patient?
8) Do the parties involve invoke fact and details supporting the objective argument?
9) Are inflammatory words, ad hominems and ad populums avoided?
10) Are both parties involved in the discussion or is the argument merely one-sided, and therefore,
5) Are all, and I repeat, all emotional arguments and feelings set aside?
6) Are subjective arguments rightly seen as irrelevant?
7) Are those involved courteous and patient?
8) Do the parties involve invoke fact and details supporting the objective argument?
9) Are inflammatory words, ad hominems and ad populums avoided?
10) Are both parties involved in the discussion or is the argument merely one-sided, and therefore,
only a harangue or rant?
11) Are the bloggers aware of civil rights, legal actions, and the entire media world of libel cases to be
11) Are the bloggers aware of civil rights, legal actions, and the entire media world of libel cases to be
avoided at all costs?
12) And most importantly, do Catholic bloggers understand that they do not merely represent themselves,
12) And most importantly, do Catholic bloggers understand that they do not merely represent themselves,
but the entire Catholic Church? There is a cult of individuality which makes many people forget they are part
of the Church and represent the Church when writing.
If we merely want to write personal views and opinions, unless our minds are like the mind of the Church,
If we merely want to write personal views and opinions, unless our minds are like the mind of the Church,
we should not call our blogs "Catholic".
Thinking like a Catholic is being in the long rational tradition of debate and manners.
Pray, reflect, think, then act. We do not have to give our opponents fire with which to burn us.
We do not have to ask for persecution, and in fact, we are to avoid it if at all possible.
To do otherwise is to both cause scandal to the Body of Christ, and to damage any chances of evangelization.
Thinking like a Catholic is being in the long rational tradition of debate and manners.
Pray, reflect, think, then act. We do not have to give our opponents fire with which to burn us.
We do not have to ask for persecution, and in fact, we are to avoid it if at all possible.
To do otherwise is to both cause scandal to the Body of Christ, and to damage any chances of evangelization.
Our first job is to save souls, not "be right". Evangelization is not the same as church politics.
Matthew 10:16
Matthew 10:16
New Revised Standard Version Catholic Edition (NRSVCE) 16 “See, I am sending you out like sheep into the
midst of wolves; so be wise as serpents and innocent as doves.
